Selection criteria and marking guide
John Snow Scholarship
For a total score out of 20.
Connection between selected piece of work and reflection
| 0 = Not demonstrated |
1 = Limited demonstration |
2 = Satisfactory demonstration |
3 = Good demonstration |
4 = Excellent demonstration |
| No connection |
Unclear, limited reflection |
Satisfactory connection |
Clear connection |
Very clear, logical connection |
Understanding of selected AFPHM competency element(s)
| 0 = Not demonstrated |
1 = Limited demonstration |
2 = Satisfactory demonstration |
3 = Good demonstration |
4 = Excellent demonstration |
| No understanding |
Superficial, limited understanding |
Satisfactory connection |
Good understanding |
Deep, comprehensive understanding |
Inclusion of key points from selected piece of work and reflection in presentation plan
| 0 = Not demonstrated |
1 = Limited demonstration |
2 = Satisfactory demonstration |
3 = Good demonstration |
4 = Excellent demonstration |
| Presentation plan contains none of the key points |
Presentation plan contains a few key points |
Presentation plan contains some key points |
Presentation plan contains most key points |
Presentation plan contains all key points |
Potential to communicate key points from selected piece of work and reflection in a 10 minute oral presentation
| 0 = Not demonstrated |
1 = Limited demonstration |
2 = Satisfactory demonstration |
3 = Good demonstration |
4 = Excellent demonstration |
| No evidence in presentation plan that these key points will be communicated effectively |
Limited evidence in presentation plan that these key points will be communicated effectively |
Some evidence in presentation plan that these key points will be communicated effectively |
Good evidence in presentation plan that these key points will be communicated effectively |
Excellent evidence in presentation plan that these key points will be communicated effectively |
Academic presentation and standard of literacy
| 0 = Not demonstrated |
1 = Limited demonstration |
2 = Satisfactory demonstration |
3 = Good demonstration |
4 = Excellent demonstration |
| Reflection and presentation plan written very poorly, with many grammar, punctuation and spelling errors |
Reflection and presentation plan written poorly, with some grammar, punctuation or spelling errors |
Reflection and presentation plan written adequately, with a few grammar, punctuation or spelling mistakes |
Reflection and presentation plan well written, with almost no grammar, punctuation or spelling errors |
Reflection and presentation plan written clearly and succinctly, with correct grammar, punctuation and spelling |
Back to the John Snow Scholarship